Some remarks about Mulholland Drive (2001) (and Mulholland Dr. (1999))
More views of - or before - Cambridge Film Festival 2016 (20 to 27 October)
(Click here to go directly to the Festival web-site)
19 August
Some remarks arising from a screening of Mulholland Drive (2001) at The Arts Picturehouse, Cambridge, on Thursday 18 August at 9.00 p.m. (and about Mulholland Dr. (1999))
Nowadays, Nicolas Winding Refn¹ seems to want to go by the cypher above (which, one learns, one may not rightly call a monogram)...
However, is he, by curating some films that have influenced him, for participating Picturehouses (@picturehouses), showing that he is not a worthy heir to Igor Stravinsky... ?
Whoever’s work they really were (or were then thought to have been), it seems that Sergei Diaghilev commissioned Stravinsky to turn some libretti and scores that he had from Naples and London, and which had been attributed to Pergolesi, into a ballet for his Ballets Russes. Again, whoever’s music Stravinsky’s Pulcinella (1920) was then thought to have been (or based on – and, not surprisingly, it does not appear that Stravinsky said otherwise), it has been known for at least the last forty years to be his adaptive reworking / re-composition of those originals (as well as being considered the first work of what is usually called his neo-classical period).
As a jumping-off point, Lynch may have had Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953), but is as likely to be recalling Eraserhead (1977) or t.v. work.— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 19, 2016
-> Including Mulholland Dr. (1999), the t.v. film of 1:28h, which preceded Mulholland Drive (2001) (2:27h)... ? https://t.co/S3lFfTyp3b— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 19, 2016
Some of the 2001 film does feel more cinematic than other parts, and can one tell when a t.v. eye is being pleased ? https://t.co/M0CLDFMhQX— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 19, 2016
-> Not to forget references to Bullets Over Broadway (1994) or Pulp Fiction (1994), let alone Sunset Blvd. (1950). https://t.co/S3lFfTgObD— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 19, 2016
The relevance of alluding to Stravinsky above lies in a sentiment that, it seems (and in mutated forms), has been ascribed to, or adopted by, many since before T. S. Eliot, but which is here quoted of Stravinsky :
Igor Stravinsky said to me of his 'Three Songs by William Shakespeare', in which he epitomized his discovery of Webern’s music : ‘A good composer does not imitate ; he steals.’
Twentieth Century Music²
In fact, does NWR, commending films to us such as Mulholland Drive (2001) (which is arguably Lynch stealing from his own t.v. film and other antecedents), really just show that he has not dared to steal, only to imitate ?
In other words, is the faulty notion behind Nicolas Winding Refn Presents... this one ? That it is as if Stravinsky had not only done very little with the Pergolesi materials to re-embody them as his own, but had also, and without good reason, allowed those facts to be known before their time.
Whereas Stravinsky himself was too good a self-publicist¹ for that, and, first allowed the Pergolesi name ‘to stick’ by arranging the work (in collaboration with Paul Kochanski) for violin and piano, publishing Suite d'après des thèmes, fragments et morceaux de Giambattista Pergolesi (1925)³...
Postlude :
Mulholland Drive leads the pack in list of 21st century's top films https://t.co/jEGS2MSOIx— The Guardian (@guardian) August 22, 2016
If David Lynch said / wanted to say, 'I’m the future. I’m the counter culture. I’m commercial reality. I’m artistic singularity.', it's OK ?— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 22, 2016
At least, when Nicolas Winding Refn seems to choose to say that about himself, it isn't ? :https://t.co/uHA5kxOHsT https://t.co/n65PJxpmzi— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 22, 2016
Top of both lists ? :https://t.co/tODRPAM5Hfhttps://t.co/Gs66bRFrIn
— THE AGENT APSLEY (@THEAGENTAPSLEY) August 27, 2016
Strangely, *not* The Neon Demon... :https://t.co/uHA5kxOHsT
End-notes
¹ Interviewed by Danny Leigh (@dannytheleigh) for The Guardian’s Film section (@guardianfilm), in Nicolas Winding Refn: 'I bring the singular, the narcissistic, the high art', NWR told Leigh – seemingly inconsequentially, as Leigh’s next paragraph is about meeting him next in London, a year later – about a young man whom he found bleeding nightmarishly in urban Los Angeles, and whom, along with another man (already there), he attempted to help, but the man died (and He had never seen anyone die before) :
He told me this story a few weeks later, still in LA. I asked if he had felt emotional. ‘No,’ he said. Nothing ? ‘Strangely nothing.’ The next morning ? ‘Nuh-uh.’ He sipped juice through a straw. ‘But later,’ he said, ‘I was happy. Because I got a fucking great idea for a scene.’
² Twentieth Century Music : Its Evolution from the End of the Harmonic Era into the Present Era of Sound, Peter Yates. Random House, New York (1967). Pantheon Books, p. 41.
³ Later, as well as an eight-movement Pulcinella Suite (revised in 1965), he produced arrangements, in collaboration with Gregor Piatigorsky and Samuel Dushkin, respectively, called Suite italienne for cello and piano (1932-1933) and violin and piano (1933).
If you want to Tweet, Tweet away here
Unless stated otherwise, all films reviewed were screened at Festival Central (Arts Picturehouse, Cambridge)
